Start Submission Become a Reviewer

Reading: A Systematic Search and Mapping Review of Studies on Intracerebral Microdialysis of Amino Ac...

Download

A- A+
Alt. Display

Review

A Systematic Search and Mapping Review of Studies on Intracerebral Microdialysis of Amino Acids, and Systematized Review of Studies on Circadian Rhythms

Authors:

Cathalijn H. C. Leenaars ,

RadboudUMC, Utrecht University, Utrecht and Nijmegen, NL; Hannover Medical School, Hannover, DE
X close

Jennifer Freymann,

University of Veterinary Medicine, DE
X close

Koen Jakobs,

RadboudUMC, Utrecht University, Utrecht and Nijmegen, NL
X close

Julia M. L. Menon,

RadboudUMC, Utrecht University, Utrecht and Nijmegen, NL
X close

Thomas J. Van Ee,

RadboudUMC, Utrecht University, Utrecht and Nijmegen, NL
X close

Janneke Elzinga,

RadboudUMC, Utrecht University, Utrecht and Nijmegen, NL
X close

Rosalie W. M. Kempkes,

RadboudUMC, Utrecht University, Utrecht and Nijmegen, NL
X close

Bea Zoer,

RadboudUMC, Utrecht University, Utrecht and Nijmegen, NL
X close

Pim W. H. I. M. Drinkenburg

Janssen Research and Development, A Division of Janssen Pharmaceutica NV, BE
X close

Abstract

Background: Microdialysis can be used to measure amino acids in the extracellular space in vivo, based on the principle of diffusion. Variations in experimental set-up result in variations in baseline levels of the compounds measured. Variations may also be due to circadian rhythms.
Method: We systematically searched and mapped the literature on all studies reporting baseline microdialysis measurements of histamine and the amino acids asparagine, aspartate, GABA, glutamate, glutamine, glycine, proline and taurine. We fully reviewed the studies describing circadian rhythms for histamine and the selected amino acids.
Results: We retrieved 2331 papers describing baseline measurements of one or more of the compounds of interest. We provide a numerical summary and lists of the publications by compound. We retrieved 11 references describing studies on the circadian rhythms of the compounds of interest. Aspartate, glutamate and histamine are generally higher during the dark than during the light phase in nocturnal rodents. For glutamine, no rhythmicity was observed. For GABA, the results were too inconsistent to generalise. For asparagine, glycine, proline and taurine, insufficient data are available.
Conclusion: The literature on intracerebral microdialysis measurements of the amino acids is vast, but certain primary studies are still warranted. Future systematic reviews on the individual compounds can shed light on the effects of experimental variations on baseline concentrations.

How to Cite: Leenaars, C.H.C., Freymann, J., Jakobs, K., Menon, J.M.L., Van Ee, T.J., Elzinga, J., Kempkes, R.W.M., Zoer, B. and Drinkenburg, P.W.H.I.M., 2018. A Systematic Search and Mapping Review of Studies on Intracerebral Microdialysis of Amino Acids, and Systematized Review of Studies on Circadian Rhythms. Journal of Circadian Rhythms, 16(1), p.12. DOI: http://doi.org/10.5334/jcr.172
174
Views
60
Downloads
  Published on 09 Oct 2018
 Accepted on 29 Sep 2018            Submitted on 17 Aug 2018

Introduction

Microdialysis is an elegant and convenient method to study the biochemistry of the extracellular space in vivo. It is based on simple diffusion; molecules diffuse from the tissue of interest into a continuously flowing isotonic fluid through a semi-permeable membrane. Microdialysis can be used to measure a variety of compounds. Concentrations of these molecules in the dialysate are not only affected by biological variations, but also by flow rate, membrane type and membrane surface area [1].

Amino acids are a set of compounds often analysed by microdialysis. Besides their function as building blocks of proteins, amino acids can function as excitatory (e.g. glutamate and aspartate) and inhibitory (e.g. GABA, glycine and taurine) neurotransmitters and neuromodulators. Amino acids are actually the most widely used neurotransmitters in the mammalian brain [2]. As neuroactive amino acids are also involved in intermediary neurotransmitter metabolism, it is difficult to analyse their transmitter role separate from their other biochemical roles [3]. Besides, brain concentration of amino acids can be altered by dietary intake [4].

Amino acids have been implied in the pathology of several neuropsychological disorders, including addiction to various compounds [5, 6, 7], ischaemia [8, 9], depression [10], Tourette’s syndrome [11], Parkinson’s disease [12], and (neuropathic) pain [13]. Histamine and the amino acids asparagine, aspartate, GABA, glutamate, glutamine, glycine, proline and taurine can be measured in a single high-pressure liquid chromatography (HPLC) run. As we are using this HPLC method to analyse microdialysis samples, we are interested in the available literature on microdialysis studies measuring these specific compounds.

In clinical medicine, systematic reviews (SRs) are considered to provide the highest level of research evidence. In animal research, SRs are, so far, less common, while SRs are the optimal method to acquire a complete overview of the past use of a technique. While many interesting narrative reviews on microdialysis are available (refer to [1] for an interesting selection), only few SRs of microdialysis have been published to date. We thus set out to perform an SR to describe all available evidence on the observed range of baseline levels of histamine and the amino acids asparagine, aspartate, GABA, glutamate, glutamine, glycine, proline and taurine in microdialysates.

With increasing numbers of literature reviews of scientific findings, the types of reviews published are also increasing [14]. Most review types do not implement an explicit methodology, resulting in limited reliability of their findings. However, several review types transparently describe their methodology and strive for an approach that is still systematic: mapping reviews, scoping reviews, and rapid reviews. According to a recent SR of published evidence maps, evidence maps comprise a systematic search of a broad field that present results in a user-friendly format [15].

The differences between SRs and systematic maps (SMs) are outlined by [16]. In general, the objective of an SM is wider and more descriptive than answering a specific research question with an SR. For an SM, data extraction is limited, and critical appraisal is optional. The SM will identify knowledge clusters and knowledge gaps but will not synthesise data from the included studies. Besides these differences, systematic mapping mainly follows the same process as systematic reviewing. Systematic evidence mapping is increasingly encouraged in the environmental sciences [17], healthcare, and social sciences [18]. Systematic mapping of animal studies has so far hardly been explored.

The number of references retrieved by our systematic search proved to be too high to complete the planned full systematic review. We thus decided to use our search results for another systematic review approach, and created a systematic map of the available literature on studies measuring histamine and the amino acids asparagine, aspartate, GABA, glutamate, glutamine, glycine, proline and taurine in animal models using microdialysis. Besides, we fully reviewed the studies describing circadian rhythms for histamine and the selected amino acids, as circadian rhythms can affect the outcomes of any microdialysis experiment.

Materials and Methods

On 12 January 2017, we published a protocol [19] for an SR addressing the research question: “What is the reported range of concentrations in intracerebral microdialysates for histamine and the amino acids asparagine, aspartate, GABA, glutamate, glutamine, glycine, proline and taurine?”. The protocol describes the used methodology for this SR up to the selection of papers.

Search

We developed a comprehensive search strategy for studies on histamine and the amino acids asparagine, aspartate, GABA, glutamate, glutamine, glycine, proline and taurine for 2 databases: PubMed and Embase. We extended our previous search strategy for microdialysis [20] by adding the terms “chemitrode”, “dialytrode”, “brain dialysis”, “intracerebral dialysis”, “intracranial dialysis”, “transcranial dialysis” and “implanted perfused hollow fibre”. We used previously published filters to identify animal studies [21, 22].

The full search strategies are described in our protocol [19]. Searches were performed on 12 and 14 December 2016. Duplicates were removed manually. We did not check reference lists of included papers or relevant reviews for additional papers, as this labour-intensive process would have retrieved only one additional paper using our improved search for microdialysis in our comparable review of adenosine [20].

Selection

Selection for mapping review

Screening of titles and abstracts was performed in EROS (Early Review Organising Software; Institute of Clinical Effectiveness and Health Policy, Buenos Aires, Argentina) by 2 independent reviewers (2 out of CL, JF, KJ, TvE, JE, RK, JvL & BZ). Subsequent screening of full-text papers was also performed by 2 independent reviewers (2 out of CL, JF, KJ & TvE). Discrepancies were resolved by discussion among the reviewers. We excluded studies on other techniques than microdialysis (e.g. biosensors and studies using precursors to microdialysis such as ventricular, cortical cup and push-pull perfusion), studies measuring other substances than histamine and the amino acids asparagine, aspartate, GABA, glutamate, glutamine, glycine, proline and taurine, extra-cerebral microdialysis studies, human and in vitro studies, and (in the full-text screening phase only) papers not containing primary study data. In the full-text screening we further excluded retro-dialysis studies and other microdialysis studies that did not report baseline values without the specified compounds in the perfusion fluid.

Selection for systematised review of circadian rhythms

During full-text screening, tags were added by KJ and CL to all studies on circadian rhythms, sleep and sleep deprivation. Tagged studies were separately screened afterwards for inclusion based on the following criterium (besides being included in our mapping): studies measuring one or more of the compounds of interest during an undisturbed baseline period of minimally 6 hours including a light-dark transition. Most of the excluded tagged studies measured for shorter periods after pharmacological interventions, or after retrodialysis of various compounds.

To ensure capturing all relevant studies, we searched for studies with the terms “*circadi*” “*period*”, “*clock*”, “*oscill*”, “*basel*”, “*pacemaker*”, “*ultradian*”, “*diurnal*”and “*rhythm*” in the list of titles of the studies included in our mapping.

Mapping

During full-text screening, labels were added to all included references by one of the screeners (CL or KJ) to reflect for which of the compound(s) of interest (histamine and the amino acids asparagine, aspartate, GABA, glutamate, glutamine, glycine, proline and taurine) baseline concentrations were provided. The EROS-file was exported to Excel, where references were sorted by these labels to create the tables provided in the appendices. An individual paper is included in multiple tables if it describes baseline dialysate concentrations of more than one compound of interest.

A subset of 140 studies was labelled by both screeners and analysed for concordance.

Systematised review

The following data were extracted for papers included in the review on circadian rhythms: bibliographic details, location of laboratory, n, species, strain, age and weight, sex, flowrate, probe length, probe diameter, membrane type, probe reuse, brain region, wash-out, anaesthesia/freely behaving, post-surgical recovery, amino acids analysed, type of analysis, light-dark cycle and summary of findings. When a reference described measurements of several amino acids and/or histamine, findings were separately tabulated for all compounds. Likewise, when references described measurements in several brain regions (e.g. the nucleus accumbens and the striatum; [23]) or for various experimental conditions (e.g. freely behaving and anaesthetised; [24]), findings were separately tabulated.

Risk of bias assessment

In our protocol, we explained that the available risk-of-bias tools are hardly applicable to baseline measurements. We thus planned to provide an indication of study quality, internal validity and risk of bias by tabulating the extracted study characteristics.

For the mapping review, only limited data were extracted, and all references are provided. We did not perform a formal risk of bias assessment for these 2331 included studies. For the studies included in our systematised review, the risk of bias was estimated by one experimenter. We added the following elements to the analysis: blinding of sample analysis for detection bias and incomplete outcome data for attrition bias, [25], and for other sources of bias: verification of probe placement, reporting of an a priori power analysis, approval of an ethical board, and conflicts of interest.

Results

Search and selection

Our search in PubMed retrieved 5118 references, that in Embase 5253. After removal of duplicates, 6239 references remained for title-abstract screening. Of these, 3144 were screened full-text, and 2331 were included in the mapping review. An overview of the flow of papers is provided in Figure 1.

Figure 1 

Flow scheme of retrieved and included references. TiAb – Title-Abstract; μD = microdialysis.

We tagged 47 references during full-text screening as relevant for circadian rhythms, sleep and sleep deprivation. Of these, 7 met the inclusion criterium for our systematised review on circadian rhythms. Our search for relevant title words added 4 references, resulting in 11 references included in our SR on circadian rhythms.

Mapping review; retrieved references by compound

The number of references retrieved by compound is provided in Table 1. The number of references by compound varies from only 6 references for proline to 1876 references for glutamate. Concordance of labelling in the subset of 140 studies ranged from 93.6% for GABA to 100% for proline. Concordance percentages are also provided in Table 1.

Table 1

Number of references by compound and concordance between screeners.

Compound Concordance in subset (%) Number of references retrieved

Asparagine 98.6 60
Aspartate 95.7 600
GABA 93.6 918
Glutamine 95.7 253
Glutamate 93.6 1876
Glycine 99.3 338
Histamine 99.3 102
Proline 100 6
Taurine 94.3 411

Only one study described the baseline microdialysate levels for all our compounds of interest [26], and 4 more described 8 out of 9 [4, 27, 28, 29]. Most of the studies reported only one (1246 studies) or two (548 studies) of these compounds. References for the included studies are provided by compound in appendix 1–9. The appendix tables can be used by scientists interested in intracerebral microdialysis of histamine and/or one or more of the analysed amino acids. The titles in a specific table can be screened one by one, or a search for title words of interest can be performed. When searching for title words, we highly recommend searching for all known synonyms of a term of interest, and searching for the first letters of the term to retrieve both the singular and the plural use and different spellings.

Systematised review on circadian rhythms in microdialysate amino acids

The 11 included references described 25 studies in 1–15 animals (9 references on rats; 5× Wistar, 4× Sprague-Dawley, 1 on mice, 1 on hamsters) in different brain regions (frontal cortex, suprachiasmatic nucleus, striatum, nucleus accumbens, basal forebrain and hypothalamus), all in English. One reference did not mention the sex of the rats, the others all used male animals only. The light schedule was adequately described by 10 out of 11 references, one only mentioned a 12 h light-dark cycle without providing actual times, but expressed the data in Zeitgeber time [30]. For the 10 papers describing the light-dark cycle, the cycle was normal (12:12, lights on at 6:00–8:00) for 7, reversed for 2 (12:12, lights on at 20:00 or 20:30), or partially reversed (12:12, lights on at 24:00 h).

Microdialysis flow rate was reported by 10 out of 11 references, and ranged from 1 to 2 μl/min. Probe lengths (0.5–4 mm) were reported by 10 out of 11 references, probe diameters (0.2–0.5 mm) by 5 out of 11. Membrane type (e.g. Hospal or CMA7) and/or molecular weight cut off (1–50 kDa) was reported by 10 out of 12 references. None of the references mentioned probe reuse. All references described HPLC for sample analysis, 9 with fluorescence detection, 1 with electrochemical detection, one with both detection types. Either histamine only (6 references), or several amino acids (5 references) were measured.

Study characteristics are provided by study and amino acid in appendix 10.

Aspartate

Table 2 lists the 2 studies on aspartate circadian rhythms. In rats, Honma et al. tested rhythmicity in freely behaving animals and under urethane anaesthesia on a 12:12 light-dark cycle [24]. Baseline dialysis commenced at different points of the light-dark cycle, and lasted 24 h. Group averages were calculated after smoothing of the individual animal data with a three-point running average. Circadian effects were tested with a two-way analysis of variance (ANOVA) which showed a significant effect. According to the authors, aspartate levels started to decrease before light onset, and increase before dark onset. In hamsters kept on a 14:10 light-dark cycle (lights on at 08:00) and measured for 24 h, Glass et al. standardised values to a percentage of the daily mean [31]. Time-of-day effects were tested by a multivariate time series analysis (MANOVA) followed by Student Newman Keuls tests. Aspartate peaked during the dark phase; 01:00–03:00 and 07:00–08:00 h.

Table 2

Microdialysis studies on aspartate circadian rhythms.

Study_ID Species Strain Brain Area Summary

Honma_1996b Rats Wistar SCN Asp is higher during the dark than during the light phase
Honma_1996d Rats Wistar SCN
Glass_1993b Hamsters Home bred SCN

SCN: SupraChiasmatic Nucleus; Asp: Aspartate.

To conclude, in the suprachiasmatic nucleus, aspartate is higher during the dark than during the light phase in both rats and hamsters, and the rhythm is also present under urethane anaesthesia [24, 31].

GABA

Table 3 lists the 3 studies on GABA circadian rhythms. Castaneda et al. sampled for 30 h starting at 14 h from rats on a 12:12 light-dark cycle; lights ON at 20:00 [23]. Values were expressed as a percentage of the average of the first 8 samples and somehow corrected for slow continuous changes in dialysate concentrations. Circadian rhythms were tested with the Cosinor method to fit the data to a sinusoidal model. If the fit was not significant, but differences between dark and light were apparent, samples 1 and 24 and samples 25 and 48 were compared with linear regression. GABA did not show circadian variation. Marquez de Prado et al. collected dialysates for 24 h after establishment of a stable baseline level [32]. Rats were on a 12:12 light-dark cycle; lights ON at 08:00. Repeated measure ANOVAs following linear regression analyses showed significant circadian variations; GABA decreased by 19% during the light period and rose to 100% of basal values at night. Meng et al. dialyzed rats on 12:12 light-dark cycle; lights ON at 07:00 [33]. Samples were collected at 2 h intervals over a 24 h period. Data were analyzed with paired-samples t-test and independent-samples t-test. The authors observed a circadian pattern with relatively high levels during the dark period and low levels during the light period.

Table 3

Microdialysis studies on GABA circadian rhythms.

Study_ID Species Strain Brain Area Summary

Castaneda_2004b Rats Wistar Striatum GABA shows no significant circadian variation, although it may be higher during dark than during light
Castaneda_2004e Rats Wistar NAcc
MarquezdePrado_2000b Rats Wistar Neostriatum GABA is higher during the dark than during the light phase
Meng_2015 Rats Spraque-Dawley Striatum

NAcc: Nucleus Accumbens; GABA: gamma-aminobutyric acid.

To conclude, results for GABA are too inconsistent to generalise [23, 32, 33].

Glutamate

Table 4 lists the 5 studies on glutamate circadian rhythms. These studies were all described above. According to Castaneda et al. glutamate followed a sinusoidal model [23]. Honma et al. state that glutamate levels started to decrease before light onset, and increase before dark onset [24]. Marquez de Prado et al. showed significant circadian variations; glutamate decreased by 37% during the light period and increased during the following dark period [32]. Glass et al. described an acrophase during the dark period [31]. Meng et al. observed a circadian pattern with relatively high levels during the dark and low levels during the light [33].

Table 4

Microdialysis studies on glutamate circadian rhythms.

Study_ID Species Strain Brain Area Summary

Castaneda_2004a Rats Wistar Striatum Glu is higher during the dark than during the light phase
Castaneda_2004d Rats Wistar NAcc
Honma_1996a Rats Wistar SCN
Honma_1996c Rats Wistar SCN
MarquezdePrado_2000a Rats Wistar Neostriatum
Glass_1993a Hamsters Home bred SCN
Meng_2015 Rats Spraque-Dawley Striatum

NAcc: Nucleus Accumbens; SCN: SupraChiasmatic Nucleus; Glu: glutamate.

To conclude, glutamate seems consistently higher during the dark than during the light phase in the suprachiasmatic nucleus in hamsters and in several brain regions in freely behaving and anaesthetised rats [23, 24, 31, 32, 33].

Glutamine

Table 5 lists the 3 studies on glutamine circadian rhythms. These studies were all described above. Castaneda et al. found no circadian variation in glutamine concentrations [23]. The study by Marquez de Prado et al. also showed no circadian rhythm for glutamine [32]. Glass et al. did not describe the glutamine findings in the text, but their figure shows that there is no significant rhythmicity for glutamine [31].

Table 5

Microdialysis studies on glutamine circadian rhythms.

Study_ID Species Strain Brain Area Summary

Castaneda_2004c Rats Wistar Striatum Gln shows no circadian rhythm
Castaneda_2004f Rats Wistar NAcc
MarquezdePrado_2000c Rats Wistar Neostriatum
Glass_1993c Hamsters homebred SCN

NAcc: Nucleus Accumbens; SCN: SupraChiasmatic Nucleus; Gln: glutamine.

To conclude, no rhythmicity is observed in glutamine in different brain regions and different species [23, 31, 32].

Histamine

Table 6 lists the 6 studies on histamine circadian rhythms. Fell et al. describe several experiments, of which one met the inclusion criteria of our systematised review [34]. Rats were kept on a 12:12 light-dark cycle; lights ON at 24:00. The circadian rhythm was not specifically analysed, but from the figures it is clear that baseline histamine increases during the dark compared to the light period. Chu et al. kept rats on a 12:12 light-dark cycle; lights ON at 08:00, and collected dialysate over 24 h [35]. The circadian rhythm was not specifically analysed, but the figure shows that baseline histamine increases during the dark compared to the light period. Hong et al. also kept rats on a 12:12 light-dark cycle; lights ON at 08:00 [36]. Dialysates were collected for 14-h starting at 20:00. The circadian rhythm was again not specifically analysed, but the figure shows that histamine is higher at the onset of the dark phase compared to the light phase. Zant et al. kept rats on an unspecified 12:12 light-dark cycle and collected dialysate over a 24 h control day [30]. The authors observed a strong correlation (r = 0.84, p < 0.001) between histamine levels and time awake, which is higher during the dark. Individual animal data also show higher histamine during dark than during light. Mochizuki et al. kept rats on a 12:12 light-dark cycle; lights ON at 08:00 [37]. They collected dialysates over variable periods of time over the circadian cycle. Averages for the light and the dark period were compared with a paired, two-tailed Student’s t-test. Average histamine concentrations were higher during dark than during light. Rozov et al. kept mice on a 12:12 light-dark cycle; lights ON at 20:30, and collected dialysate for five consecutive days [38]. Data were analysed with the Lomb–Scargle method using LSP software. The authors found 24-h and overlaid 8-h periodicities in histamine release, with an orthophase at 17:63.

Table 6

Microdialysis studies on histamine circadian rhythms.

Study_ID Species Strain Brain Area Summary

Fell_2015 Rat Spraque-Dawley mPFC Hist is higher during the dark than during the light phase
Chu_2004 Rats Spraque-Dawley Frontal cortex
Hong_2005 Rats Spraque-Dawley Frontal cortex
Zant_2012 Rat Han-Wistar BF
Mochizuki_1992 Rats Wistar Hypothalamus
Rozov_2014 Mice C57BL6/J Hypothalamus

mPFC: medial Prefrontal Cortex; BF: Basal Forebrain; Hist: histamine.

To conclude, histamine seems consistently higher during the dark than during the light phase in the hypothalamus in mice and in several brain regions in rats [34, 35, 36, 37, 38, 39].

Taurine

Only one included reference measured taurine; in the neostriatum of Wistar rats. This study by Marquez de Prado et al. was described above [32]. Taurine showed no circadian rhythm.

Asparagine, Glycine and Proline

Our search retrieved no studies of circadian rhythms in asparagine, glycine and proline.

Risk of Bias

Reporting of study characteristics was analysed by reference. None of the included references described blinding of sample analysis, missing samples or power analyses. Only 1 out of 11 references contained a statement on conflicts of interest. Approval of the protocol by an ethical board was reported in 6 out of 11 references. Methods for verification of probe placement were reported in 8 out of 11 references, but only 3 showed the results.

Concluding, the risk of bias is unclear for all included studies.

Discussion

Our systematic map provides an overview of the papers describing baseline microdialysis measurements of histamine and the amino acids asparagine, aspartate, GABA, glutamate, glutamine, glycine, proline and taurine. In our results section, we describe how scientists can use this systematic map, to save the time involved in performing a systematic search and selection for one or more of the analysed compounds themselves. In our systematized review, we provide an example.

The map shows that many more microdialysis studies have measured glutamate and GABA than proline and histamine. This partially echoes researchers interests in compounds as a neurotransmitter but is probably also reflecting the relative ease of measuring glutamate in dialysates. Included studies describe analytical methods [40, 41], functional neuroanatomy [42, 43], basic pharmacology [44, 45], the neurochemistry of behaviour [46, 47, 48], and the neurochemistry of several disorders (described in the introduction).

The 11 references on circadian rhythms show a relative abundance of studies on histamine, but none of them addressed asparagine, glycine or proline, and only one was on taurine. Aspartate, glutamate and histamine are generally higher during the dark than during the light phase in nocturnal rodents. For glutamine, no rhythmicity was observed. For GABA, the results were too inconsistent to generalise. For asparagine, GABA, glycine, proline and taurine, further primary studies on circadian rhythms are warranted.

Several authors have published SRs on the microdialysis technique, but we are aware of only one SR on amino acids [49]. Fliegel et al. performed an SR followed by several meta-analyses of glutamate and GABA in relation to ethanol exposure. We do not know if they followed a prespecified review protocol. Their search was more focussed than ours, they used key search terms and searched one database, which resulted in a selection of the available literature; 245 studies reporting baseline glutamate and or GABA levels. While methodology of this SR was not described to the extent that we can evaluate its quality, it provides extremely useful overviews of the baseline concentrations of glutamate and GABA for several brain regions.

Our comprehensive search strategy makes this the most complete review of amino acids in microdialysates up to date. We based our search for microdialysis studies on previous work [20] and extended it by including the terms “chemitrode”, “dialytrode”, “brain dialysis”, “intracerebral dialysis”, “intracranial dialysis”, “transcranial dialysis” and “implanted perfused hollow fibre” to improve retrieval of older studies.

Because the size of the review was larger than anticipated, we had to adapt our protocol. By our labelling approach we managed to create a map of the literature by amino acid of interest. We only labelled studies for measurements of asparagine, aspartate, GABA, glutamate, glutamine, glycine, histamine, proline and taurine. In the included papers, we regularly came across microdialysis measurements of other amino acids, e.g. alanine, serine, and threonine. Future systematic reviews should summarise the findings for these compounds.

Labelling was performed by one of the screeners. We analysed concordance in a subset of 140 papers. Concordance ranged from 93.6% to 100%. We did not reanalyse the discordant papers to determine if they are erroneously included or if they were missed by one of the screeners. There thus is a risk of both missing relevant studies and errors of overinclusion. However, the margin of error is quite likely smaller than when using non-systematic search approaches.

Tagging and/or labelling of references on specific topics during screening for large reviews is an interesting approach to increase the output and relevance of review efforts. Our labelling for amino acids seems rather reliable, with concordance >93%. Our tagging for studies on circadian rhythms was less successful, we tagged only 7 of the 11 references included in our systematised review. Possibly, this was due to a loss of focus. Tagging did have added value; we included 4 references via tags that would not have been found with our title search. Of note, our searches also retrieved publications on other than circadian biological rhythms, e.g. circannual rhythms, [50] reflecting the limited specificity of searching for text words in general. When using the tagging/labelling strategy for future reviews, we advise against labelling for 2 topics simultaneously, and to restrict labelling to straightforward concepts (e.g. well-defined chemical compounds).

The provided lists of references in our mapping review can be used as the basis for systematic reviews for future projects. We envision for example rapid review strategies for certain fields based on searches for title words within the larger tables (e.g. for glutamate), or on screening of all the titles in one of the smaller tables (e.g. histamine).

We provide such a systematized review of circadian rhythms as a proof of concept. This review shows circadian rhythms for aspartate, glutamate and histamine, and no rhythmicity for glutamine. Next to this review, a second review of the studies about natural sleep and sleep deprivation is in progress. Our systematic map is relevant to all neurochemists; it is not specific to the field of chronobiology. We chose to present it with our systematised review of the circadian data as systematic reviews are still relatively scarce in animal chronobiology. We thus hope to inspire chronobiologists to use more systematised review strategies. We highly encourage anyone performing a meta-analysis on microdialysis data to address the effects of variations in experimental design, as done, for example, in [20, 51, 52].

Data Accessibility Statement

Data in this publication are already in the public domain. Extracted data will be made available for reuse to individual scientists upon reasonable requests.

Additional Files

The additional files for this article can be found as follows:

Appendix 1

Studies describing baseline dialysate concentrations for asparagine. DOI: https://doi.org/10.5334/jcr.172.s1

Appendix 2

Studies describing baseline dialysate concentrations for aspartate. DOI: https://doi.org/10.5334/jcr.172.s1

Appendix 3

Studies describing baseline dialysate concentrations for GABA. DOI: https://doi.org/10.5334/jcr.172.s1

Appendix 4

Studies describing baseline dialysate concentrations for glutamine. DOI: https://doi.org/10.5334/jcr.172.s1

Appendix 5

Studies describing baseline dialysate concentrations for glutamate. DOI: https://doi.org/10.5334/jcr.172.s1

Appendix 6

Studies describing baseline dialysate concentrations for glycine. DOI: https://doi.org/10.5334/jcr.172.s1

Appendix 7

Studies describing baseline dialysate concentrations for histamine. DOI: https://doi.org/10.5334/jcr.172.s1

Appendix 8

Studies describing baseline dialysate concentrations for proline. DOI: https://doi.org/10.5334/jcr.172.s1

Appendix 9

Studies describing baseline dialysate concentrations for taurine. DOI: https://doi.org/10.5334/jcr.172.s1

Appendix 10

Study characteristics for microdialysis studies on circadian rhythms of aspartate, GABA, glutamine, glutamate and histamine. DOI: https://doi.org/10.5334/jcr.172.s1

Acknowledgements

ZonMW (114024103), the DFG (FOR2591, BL 953/11-1) and the Federal State of Lower Saxony (R2N) provided funding for this project. The authors would like to thank Rob de Vries and Judith van Luijk for advice in protocol development, Alice Tillema for help in optimising the search strategy, and Judith van Luijk and Katya Tsaioun for assistance in screening.

Competing Interests

The authors have no competing interests to declare.

Author Contributions

CL, JF, TvE, BZ & PD designed the systematic review. CL, JF, KJ, JM, TvE, JE, RK and BZ performed the systematic review. CL analysed the data. CL wrote the manuscript, which all other authors reviewed.

References

  1. Westerink, BHC and Cremers, TIFH. Handbook of Microdialysis – Methods, Applications and Perspectives. Amsterdam, the Netherlands: Elsevier – Academic Press; 2007. 

  2. Feldman, RS, Meyer, JS and Quenzer, LF. Principles of Neuropsychopharmacology. Sunderland, Massachusetts: Sinauer Associates, Inc.; 1997. 

  3. Cooper, JR, Bloom, FE and Roth, RH. The Biochemical Basis of Neuropharmacology. New York: Oxford University Press; 2003. 

  4. Choi, YH, Chang, N, Fletcher, PJ and Anderson, GH. Dietary protein content affects the profiles of extracellular amino acids in the medial preoptic area of freely moving rats. Life Sci. 2000; 66: 1105–1118. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/S0024-3205(00)00414-8 

  5. Aghajanian, GK, Kogan, JH and Moghaddam, B. Opiate withdrawal increases glutamate and aspartate efflux in the locus coeruleus: An in vivo microdialysis study. Brain Res. 1994; 636: 126–130. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/0006-8993(94)90186-4 

  6. Ding, ZM, Ingraham, CM, Lasek, AW, Hauser, SR, Bell, RL and McBride, WJ. Differences in cortico-limbic MGLUR2 levels of alcohol-preferring (P) and wistar rats: Dissociation with glutamate transmission and alcohol drinking. Alcoholism: Clinical and Experimental Research. 2016; 40: 28A. 

  7. Shin, CB, Serchia, MM, Shahin, JR, Ruppert-Majer, MA, Kippin, TE and Szumlinski, KK. Incubation of cocaine-craving relates to glutamate over-flow within ventromedial prefrontal cortex. Neuropharmacology. 2016; 102: 103–110. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.neuropharm.2015.10.038 

  8. Baker, AJ, Zornow, MH, Scheller, MS, Yaksh, TL, Skilling, SR, Smullin, DH, Larson, AA and Kuczenski, R. Changes in extracellular concentrations of glutamate, aspartate, glycine, dopamine, serotonin, and dopamine metabolites after transient global ischemia in the rabbit brain. J Neurochem. 1991; 57: 1370–1379. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1471-4159.1991.tb08303.x 

  9. Vondrakova, K, Vales, K, Kubova, H, Kacer, P and Tsenov, G. Neurochemical changes in the endothelin-1 model of focal cerebral ischemia in immature rats. Epilepsia. 2016; 57: 46. 

  10. Rappeneau, V, Blaker, A, Petro, JR, Yamamoto, BK and Shimamoto, A. Disruption of the Glutamate-Glutamine Cycle Involving Astrocytes in an Animal Model of Depression for Males and Females. Front Behav Neurosci. 2016; 10: 231. DOI: https://doi.org/10.3389/fnbeh.2016.00231 

  11. Zhang, W, Wei, L, Yu, W, Cui, X, Liu, X, Wang, Q and Wang, S. Effect of Jian-Pi-Zhi-Dong Decoction on striatal glutamate and gamma-aminobutyric acid levels detected using microdialysis in a rat model of Tourette syndrome. Neuropsychiatr Dis Treat. 2016; 12: 1233–1242. DOI: https://doi.org/10.2147/NDT.S106330 

  12. Yelkenli, IH, Ulupinar, E, Korkmaz, OT, Sener, E, Kus, G, Filiz, Z and Tuncel, N. Modulation of Corpus Striatal Neurochemistry by Astrocytes and Vasoactive Intestinal Peptide (VIP) in Parkinsonian Rats. J Mol Neurosci. 2016; 59: 280–289. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s12031-016-0757-0 

  13. Kelly, CJ, Huang, M, Meltzer, H and Martina, M. Reduced Glutamatergic Currents and Dendritic Branching of Layer 5 Pyramidal Cells Contribute to Medial Prefrontal Cortex Deactivation in a Rat Model of Neuropathic Pain. Front Cell Neurosci. 2016; 10: 133. DOI: https://doi.org/10.3389/fncel.2016.00133 

  14. Grant, MJ and Booth, A. A typology of reviews: An analysis of 14 review types and associated methodologies. Health Info Libr J. 2009; 26: 91–108. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1471-1842.2009.00848.x 

  15. Miake-Lye, IM, Hempel, S, Shanman, R and Shekelle, PG. What is an evidence map? A systematic review of published evidence maps and their definitions, methods, and products. Syst Rev. 2016; 5: 28. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1186/s13643-016-0204-x 

  16. James, KL, Randall, NP and Haddaway, NR. A methodology for systematic mapping in environmental sciences. Environmental evidence. 2016; 5. 

  17. O’Leary, BC, Woodcock, P, Kaiser, MJ and Pullin, AS. Evidence maps and evidence gaps: Evidence review mapping as a method for collating and appraising evidence reviews to inform research and policy. Environmental evidence. 2017; 6: 1–9. 

  18. Snilstveit, A, Vojtkova, M, Bhavsar, A, Stevenson, J and Gaarder, M. Evidence & Gap Maps: A tool for promoting evidence informed policy and strategic research agendas. J Clin Epidemiology. 2016; 79: 120–129. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jclinepi.2016.05.015 

  19. Amino acids in microdialysates (protocol). 

  20. Van der Mierden, S, Savelyev, SA, IntHout, J, De Vries, RBM and Leenaars, CH. Intracerebral microdialysis of adenosine and AMP – a systematic review and meta-regression analysis. J Neurochem; 2018. [Epub ahead of print]. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1111/jnc.14552 

  21. de Vries, RB, Hooijmans, CR, Tillema, A, Leenaars, M and Ritskes-Hoitinga, M. Updated version of the Embase search filter for animal studies. Lab Anim. 2014; 48: 88. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1177/0023677213494374 

  22. Hooijmans, CR, Tillema, A, Leenaars, M and Ritskes-Hoitinga, M. Enhancing search efficiency by means of a search filter for finding all studies on animal experimentation in PubMed. Lab Anim. 2010; 44: 17–175. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1258/la.2010.009117 

  23. Castaneda, TR, de Prado, BM, Prieto, D and Mora, F. Circadian rhythms of dopamine, glutamate and GABA in the striatum and nucleus accumbens of the awake rat: Modulation by light. J Pineal Res. 2004; 177–185. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1046/j.1600-079X.2003.00114.x 

  24. Honma, S, Katsuno, Y, Shinohara, K, Abe, H and Honma, K. Circadian rhythm and response to light of extracellular glutamate and aspartate in rat suprachiasmatic nucleus. Am J Physiol. 1996; R579–585. 

  25. Hooijmans, CR, Rovers, MM, de Vries, RB, Leenaars, M, Ritskes-Hoitinga, M and Langendam, MW. SYRCLE’s risk of bias tool for animal studies. BMC Med Res Methodol. 2014; 14: 43. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1186/1471-2288-14-43 

  26. Wong, JM, Malec, PA, Mabrouk, OS, Ro, J, Dus, M and Kennedy, RT. Benzoyl chloride derivatization with liquid chromatography-mass spectrometry for targeted metabolomics of neurochemicals in biological samples. J Chromatogr A. 2016; 1446: 78–90. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.chroma.2016.04.006 

  27. Acworth, IN, Yu, J, Ryan, E, Gariepy, KC, Gamache, P, Hull, K and Maher, T. Simultaneous measurement of monoamine, amino acid, and drug levels, using high performance liquid chromatography and coulometric array technology: Application to in vivo microdialysis perfusate analysis. Journal of Liquid Chromatography. 1994; 17: 685–705. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/10826079408013169 

  28. Li, H and Yan, ZY. Analysis of amino acid neurotransmitters in hypothalamus of rats during cerebral ischemia-reperfusion by microdialysis and capillary electrophoresis. Biomed Chromatogr. 2010; 24: 1185–1192. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1002/bmc.1425 

  29. Qu, Y, Li, Y, Vandenbussche, E, Vandesande, F and Arckens, L. In vivo microdialysis in the visual cortex of awake cat. II: Sample analysis by microbore HPLC-electrochemical detection and capillary electrophoresis-laser-induced fluorescence detection. Brain Res Brain Res Protoc. 2001; 7: 45–51. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/S1385-299X(00)00061-1 

  30. Zant, JC, Rozov, S, Wigren, HK, Panula, P and Porkka-Heiskanen, T. Histamine release in the basal forebrain mediates cortical activation through cholinergic neurons. J Neurosci. 2012; 13244–13254. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1523/JNEUROSCI.5933-11.2012 

  31. Glass, JD, Hauser, UE, Blank, JL, Selim, M and Rea, MA. Differential timing of amino acid and 5-HIAA rhythms in suprachiasmatic hypothalamus. Am J Physiol. 1993; R504–511. 

  32. Marquez de Prado, B, Castaneda, TR, Galindo, A, del Arco, A, Segovia, G, Reiter, RJ and Mora, F. Melatonin disrupts circadian rhythms of glutamate and GABA in the neostriatum of the aware rat: A microdialysis study. J Pineal Res. 2000; 209–216. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1034/j.1600-0633.2002.290403.x 

  33. Meng, T, Yuan, S, Zheng, Z, Liu, T and Lin, L. Effects of endogenous melatonin on glutamate and GABA rhythms in the striatum of unilateral 6-hydroxydopamine-lesioned rats. Neuroscience. 2015; 308–315. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.neuroscience.2014.11.062 

  34. Fell, MJ, Flik, G, Dijkman, U, Folgering, JH, Perry, KW, Johnson, BJ, Westerink, BH and Svensson, KA. Glutamatergic regulation of brain histamine neurons: In vivo microdialysis and electrophysiology studies in the rat. Neuropharmacology. 2015; 1–8. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.neuropharm.2015.05.034 

  35. Chu, M, Huang, ZL, Qu, WM, Eguchi, N, Yao, MH and Urade, Y. Extracellular histamine level in the frontal cortex is positively correlated with the amount of wakefulness in rats. Neurosci Res. 2004; 417–420. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.neures.2004.05.001 

  36. Hong, ZY, Huang, ZL, Qu, WM and Eguchi, N. Orexin A promotes histamine, but not norepinephrine or serotonin, release in frontal cortex of mice. Acta Pharmacol Sin. 2005; 155–159. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1745-7254.2005.00523.x 

  37. Mochizuki, T, Yamatodani, A, Okakura, K, Horii, A, Inagaki, N and Wada, H. Circadian rhythm of histamine release from the hypothalamus of freely moving rats. Physiol Behav. 1992; 391–394. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/0031-9384(92)90157-W 

  38. Rozov, SV, Zant, JC, Karlstedt, K, Porkka-Heiskanen, T and Panula, P. Periodic properties of the histaminergic system of the mouse brain. Eur J Neurosci. 2014; 218–228. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1111/ejn.12397 

  39. Zant, JC, Rozov, S, Wigren, HK, Panula, P and Porkka-Heiskanen, T. Cholinergic basal forebrain neurons mediate histamineinduced cortical activation. Journal of Sleep Research. 2012; 263. 

  40. Gobert, A, Rivet, JM, Billiras, R, Parsons, F and Millan, MJ. Simultaneous quantification of D- vs. L-serine, taurine, kynurenate, phosphoethanolamine and diverse amino acids in frontocortical dialysates of freely-moving rats: Differential modulation by N-methyl-D-aspartate (NMDA) and other pharmacological agents. J Neurosci Methods. 2011; 202: 143–157. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jneumeth.2011.08.040 

  41. Chen, R, Deng, Y, Yang, L, Wang, J and Xu, F. Determination of Histamine by High-Performance Liquid Chromatography After Precolumn Derivatization with o-Phthalaldehyde-Sulfite. J Chromatogr Sci. 2016; 54: 547–553. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1093/chromsci/bmv185 

  42. Beitz, AJ. Relationship of glutamate and aspartate to the periaqueductal gray-raphe magnus projection: Analysis using immunocytochemistry and microdialysis. J Histochem Cytochem. 1990; 38: 1755–1765. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1177/38.12.1701457 

  43. Beggiato, S, Tomasini, MC, Borelli, AC, Borroto-Escuela, DO, Fuxe, K, Antonelli, T, Tanganelli, S and Ferraro, L. Functional role of striatal A2A, D2, and mGlu5 receptor interactions in regulating striatopallidal GABA neuronal transmission. J Neurochem. 2016; 138: 254–264. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1111/jnc.13652 

  44. Anderson, JJ and DiMicco, JA. The use of microdialysis for studying the regional effects of pharmacological manipulation on extracellular levels of amino acids—some methodological aspects. Life Sci. 1992; 51: 623–630. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/0024-3205(92)90232-E 

  45. Zestos, AG, Mikelman, SR, Kennedy, RT and Gnegy, ME. PKCbeta Inhibitors Attenuate Amphetamine-Stimulated Dopamine Efflux. ACS Chem Neurosci. 2016; 7: 757–766. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1021/acschemneuro.6b00028 

  46. Ballini, C, Corte, LD, Pazzagli, M, Colivicchi, MA, Pepeu, G, Tipton, KF and Giovannini, MG. Extracellular levels of brain aspartate, glutamate and GABA during an inhibitory avoidance response in the rat. J Neurochem. 2008; 106: 1035–1043. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1471-4159.2008.05452.x 

  47. Bianchi, L, Ballini, C, Colivicchi, MA, Della Corte, L, Giovannini, MG and Pepeu, G. Investigation on acetylcholine, aspartate, glutamate and GABA extracellular levels from ventral hippocampus during repeated exploratory activity in the rat. Neurochem Res. 2003; 28: 565–573. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1023/A:1022881625378 

  48. Suzuki, S, Saitoh, A, Ohashi, M, Oka, JI and Yamada, M. The infralimbic and prelimbic medial prefrontal cortices have differential functions in the expression of anxiety-like behaviors in mice. Behavioural Brain Research. 2016; 304: 120–124. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.bbr.2016.01.044 

  49. Fliegel, S, Brand, I, Spanagel, R and Noori, HR. Ethanol-induced alterations of amino acids measured by in vivo microdialysis in rats: A meta-analysis. In Silico Pharmacol. 2013; 1: 7. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1186/2193-9616-1-7 

  50. Parrot, S, Bert, L, Renaud, B and Denoroy, L. Large inter-experiment variations in microdialysate aspartate and glutamate in rat striatum may reflect a circannual rhythm. Synapse. 2001; 267–269. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1002/1098-2396(20010301)39:3<267::AID-SYN1008>3.0.CO;2-W 

  51. Brand, I, Fliegel, S, Spanagel, R and Noori, HR. Global ethanol-induced enhancements of monoaminergic neurotransmission: A meta-analysis study. Alcohol Clin Exp Res. 2013; 37: 2048–2057. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1111/acer.12207 

  52. Frank, ST, Krumm, B and Spanagel, R. Cocaine-induced dopamine overflow within the nucleus accumbens measured by in vivo microdialysis: A meta-analysis. Synapse. 2008; 62: 243–252. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1002/syn.20489 

comments powered by Disqus